Compare Financial Products Side by Side

Pick up to three listings from the directory, then weigh them against each other on the attributes that decide the choice — fees, minimums, features, regulation and ratings.

Add listings to compare

2 of 3 selected

Featured — quick add

What you're comparing

You have 2 listings in the compare tray: Fidelity 500 Index Fund (FXAIX) (S&P 500 mutual fund) and American Funds American Balanced (ABALX) (Balanced fund). Below, each row shows the attribute, what it measures, and which listing leads when the value can be ranked numerically.

Top ratedFidelity 500 Index Fund (FXAIX)

S&P 500 mutual fund

American Funds American Balanced (ABALX)

Balanced fund

Rating 4.8 (290) 4.3 (110)
Expense ratio
(lower is better)
Annual cost as a percentage of assets — compounds heavily inside long-horizon retirement accounts.
0.015%0.55%
Minimum
(lower is better)
Initial deposit required to open the fund; can be a hard barrier inside taxable brokerage accounts.
$0$250
Load
Sales charge at purchase or sale — most modern funds are no-load, but legacy share classes still carry one.
None5.75% (A share)
Category
Morningstar style and asset-class bucket; lets you compare against true peers, not the whole market.
Large blendModerate allocation
RegulationSEC, Investment Company Act 1940SEC, Investment Company Act 1940
Pros
  • + Easy automation of contributions
  • + Wide availability inside retirement accounts
  • + Many low-cost index options
  • + Easy automation of contributions
  • + Wide availability inside retirement accounts
  • + Many low-cost index options
Cons
  • Trades only at end-of-day NAV
  • Some funds carry sales loads or 12b-1 fees
  • Less tax-efficient than equivalent ETFs
  • Trades only at end-of-day NAV
  • Some funds carry sales loads or 12b-1 fees
  • Less tax-efficient than equivalent ETFs
HeadquartersBoston, MA, United StatesLos Angeles, CA, United States
Founded20111975
License
Experience levelBeginnerBeginner
Visit

Bottom line

Across the attributes that can be ranked numerically: Fidelity 500 Index Fund (FXAIX) leads on expense ratio (0.015%); Fidelity 500 Index Fund (FXAIX) leads on minimum ($0). Use this as a starting point — your own situation (account type, deposit size, jurisdiction) decides which of those leads actually matters.

How to use this comparison

Side-by-side comparisons make trade-offs visible — but only if you compare on the dimensions that actually drive the decision. A 0.10% expense-ratio difference between two near-identical broad-market ETFs is real, but rarely the deciding factor for a $5,000 investment. A 5-year track record difference between two robo-advisors usually matters less than whether they support the account type you need.

Before you commit to one option, write down two or three deal-breakers. Maybe it's "must support a SEP IRA". Maybe it's "must have a no-fee checking account included". Filter against those first, then look at marginal differences.

Where possible, every numeric attribute in the table is sourced from the business's own disclosures or a regulator filing. We refresh claimed and verified listings on at least a quarterly cycle; unclaimed listings rely on our last editor review, and we mark the date so you can judge how recent the information is.

Frequently asked questions

Related MoneyMoodBoard guides